The Epistemology of Boundary Conditions: Between Necessity and Happenstance
In this talk, Bursten uses examples from classical physics and nanoscience to argue
that in many physical systems, factors besides the natural laws occupy essential roles
in explanation. While extra-nomological factors have long been recognized as elements
of scientific explanations (e.g. as Hempel’s so-called “determining conditions”),
most philosophical work on physical explanations has focused on the roles of law-like
regularities and/or the cause–effect relationship in generating satisfying explanations
of physical phenomena. Bursten focuses instead on the epistemological role of a particular
sort of configurational constraint, namely the boundary
conditions on boundary value models in physics, to show that these extra-nomological
factors play at least three sorts of irreducible roles in physical explanation: (1)
they suppress information about differences of configuration that don’t make a difference
to the physical explanation of the system, (2) they describe what Cartwright has called
“causal powers,” and (3) they constrain what Winsberg has called the “handshakes”
between different physical theories that underwrite multi-scale modeling and explanations
of multi-scale phenomena.
connect with us